When an accretive acquisition can destroy value
Compare the earnings-per-share result with what the acquired cash flows are worth.
Wall Street Playbook ·
Interview case and solution
An acquirer earns $100m on 100m shares. It pays $180m from idle cash for a business generating $15m of normalized annual earnings and free cash flow. Ignore foregone interest, fees, and deal accounting in the EPS calculation. Value the target as a no-growth perpetuity at a 10% required return.
EPS increases from $1.00 to $1.15, or 15% accretion. The target is worth $15m / 10% = $150m on those assumptions. Paying $180m produces negative $30m of NPV. A permanent $3m annual increase in free cash flow would make the purchase break even before extra integration costs.
Say it aloud
“Accretion says earnings per share rise. The valuation says those cash flows are worth $30m less than the purchase price unless we can close the gap.”
Finance Technical Interview Guide
Get the complete guide when you’re ready for more practice.
Sale price $67.15 Original price $79