Disagreeing with a senior colleague in a banking interview
Show how you raised a material concern, tested it, and handled the decision once it was made.
Wall Street Playbook ·
Sample answer structure
A senior colleague wants to use a peer at 15× in a comps exhibit. The analyst notices that the peer recently divested a segment still included in the consensus earnings period being used. The analyst refreshes the denominator where possible and produces the range with and without the name. In a separate conversation, they explain the source difference and propose flagging the comp. The colleague keeps the company in the appendix with the caveat.
Prepare for a follow-up
If asked what you would do if the senior colleague rejected the caveat, distinguish a defensible presentation choice from a material number you know is wrong. Explain how you would keep the responsible reviewer informed and document the basis of the analysis. Avoid describing a disagreement you only heard about secondhand.
Behavioral Interview Guide
Get the complete guide when you’re ready for more practice.
Sale price $24.65 Original price $29